Foreign exchange rate and the greed of €14k fees

Don’t run the gauntlet of greedy exchange rate pickpockets before you leave on holiday. Peter McGahan explains how to side step unnecessary costs.
exchange rate
Summer travels can bring some pretty hefty exchange rate costs if you don’t plan ahead.

Having spent the last two years cooped up like chickens, holiday makers around the world have been taking the opportunity to make for the hills and experience different cultures/food, but not the weather as its been perfect here indeed.

As is often the case, they run the gauntlet of the greedy, pickpocketing them financially before they leave.

I covered the potential for the euro/sterling rate last week. I think the dollar rate is more obvious in that we would expect sterling to remain weak given its vulnerabilities, but the euro is less obvious versus sterling (they both have big threats).

Exchange rate tips

When booking a flight and you are asked if you want to pay using a ‘guaranteed rate’ such as that offered by Ryanair, consider your offer. Today, as I write this, the rate offered was €111.19 per £100. If I choose the mid-market rate today I can achieve €118.73, and if I use a card without currency charges or a prepay card like Starling or Revolut, I will receive €118.51 – roughly six per cent more. If you take care of the pennies the pounds take care of themselves. It’s much better to pay in the currency they are asking for and then use a card that doesn’t have currency charges like Nationwide, Halifax Clarity.

The same applies in a shop abroad. When asked if you would like to pay in your own currency (like it’s some sort of favour), they load a currency exchange rate that may well be close to around four per cent. What a favour! – It’s a bit like helping a fish up a tree so it doesn’t drown.

Maybe you want to take some cash with you abroad?

I shouldn’t bother. The prepay card above offers €118.73, whereas holiday money delivery companies’ rates can be pretty horrific for smaller amounts less than £700. Above £700, they range from a 1.173 exchange rate to a dreadful 1.15 (as opposed to 1.187 above), but they also layer on delivery fees and general fees with the actual rate received as 1.17 at the top end and 1.14 at the bottom. (For the record I’m only assessing the top 15 companies).

The exchange rate no-no

From a security point of view, I prefer the prepay cards like Starling. Carrying cash, taking cash out, and using credit cards, all have their significant risks, but the ability to move to your phone and freeze your card in a second has its advantages (somewhat faster than making your way through countless options on a Saturday to be told there is no one there).

As for changing cash at an airport – you have to be desperate. Don’t do it. I won’t scare you with the numbers.

There are other reasons to transfer cash abroad, and you need to be equally careful with those options. For example, you may be either sending a deposit abroad for a home, or even the full cash for the purchase, earning abroad and transferring back, or even emigrating.

These numbers are even scarier. In short, stay clear of any bank.

Once again if I stick to the top available options, the numbers are horrendous. The top performer is the broker I’ve used for many years, Torfx with a transfer of £400,000 achieving €474,472 from an exchange rate at the time of writing of 1.186.

At the bottom of this pile (and there are plenty beyond it) is HSBC and Barclays. HSBC has an exchange rate of 1.149 and an astonishing £10 fee, giving you €459,592, while Barclays is giving you €460,078. This is a charge of a mind-blowing €14,880 by going to your high street bank, that often aren’t on the high street.

If you know a rate that would be good for you, you can set a limit order with your broker. They will execute the trade when it reaches that amount.

You could also set what is called a stop loss order which controls the risk of an exchange rate surprising you with a sharp fall.

Finally, if peace of mind is important, you can set a forward price for up to two years for a transfer if you like the rate right now, safe in the knowledge it cannot move. If you have a financial question about the content of this column, you can call 01872 222422, email [email protected] or visit

If you found Foreign exchange rate and the greed of €14k fees helpful, you’ll find more thrifty spending tips on our Finance channel.

Tags: , , Last modified: August 22, 2022

Written by 9:54 am Money Saving Tips, Finance